String Cheese Fingers / Severed Fingers / Witches’ Fingers
Prep time
Total time
Give your kids a bit of a fright with these realistic String Cheese Fingers. If serving on a plate, amp up the fright factor by adding ketchup or hot sauce for a “bloody” effect that will scare even the bravest of souls.
Recipe type: Snacks
Cuisine: American
Serves: 6
  • 3 String Cheeses
  • Peanut Butter
  • 6 Almond Slices
  1. Unwrap a piece of string cheese. Cut in half.
  2. Dab a tiny amount of peanut butter, or any other sticky binding agent, on one end of the cheese stick.
  3. Place an almond slice on top of the binder to form a “fingernail.”
  4. If desired, enhance the life-like quality of this treat by slicing slits in the center of each cheese stick to imitate knuckle creases.
Recipe by Sarah Koszyk at